Who is Susan Marie Cox?

In the shadowy world of unsolved mysteries, the story of Susan Powell stands as a haunting tale of family secrets, shattered innocence, and the bleak reminder of the darkness that can lurk within the most ordinary looking families. Before her name became synonymous with one of the most confounding missing person cases of recent years, Susan was just a bright-eyed, vivacious young woman striving for happiness like any other. This is where our journey begins, as we dive into the heart of a story that continues to reverberate long after the headlines have faded.

Susan Marie Cox, better known as Susan Powell, was born on October 16, 1981, in the quiet town of Alamogordo, New Mexico. The third of four children in a devoutly religious Cox family, her upbringing was steeped in the values of the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints (LDS). Childhood memories, photographs, and accounts paint a picture of a cheerful girl who was full of life and ambition. A beam of light that could effortlessly illuminate any room, Susan was, by all accounts, a person who exuded positivity and warmth.

Her life took a significant turn when she crossed paths with Joshua Powell at a local LDS function. Joshua, a fellow LDS member, was a man who carried an air of charm that, to Susan and those around her, seemed perfectly in tune with her vivacious personality. Their shared faith and common interests acted as the perfect catalyst for a budding romance, and they soon found themselves walking down the aisle, promising to spend their lives together in 2001. However, little did Susan know that this marriage would be the prologue to a series of deeply troubling events that would eventually cast a long, eerie shadow over her once idyllic existence.

From the outside, Susan and Joshua presented the image of a quintessential happy couple. However, behind closed doors, the reality was far different, slowly spiraling into a dark abyss that Susan would eventually be unable to escape from. As we go deeper into Susan Powell’s life and mysterious disappearance, we’re left grappling with a chilling paradox – a radiant, ambitious woman drawn into a vortex of grim events that would ultimately consume her. The façade of normality that shrouded the Powell family held a sinister underbelly, one that would only be revealed as the puzzle pieces of Susan’s life began to unravel.

The Disappearance of Susan Powell

In the dead of winter, on December 6, 2009, Susan Powell vanished without a trace from her home in West Valley City, Utah. A sudden void enveloped the everyday routine of this young mother of two, marking the beginning of a mystery that continues to baffle investigators to this day. The days and hours leading up to Susan’s disappearance provide a chilling tableau of events that would eventually set the stage for one of the most perplexing missing person cases in American history.

On the evening of December 6, Joshua Powell claimed to have taken his sons, Charles and Braden, on an impromptu camping trip in the middle of a blizzard. Joshua’s choice to venture out into the harsh winter wilderness with two toddlers in tow, at an hour where most families would be safely tucked into bed, was puzzling to say the least. Even more so, was the fact that when they returned home, Susan was nowhere to be found.

The alarm bells started ringing when Susan didn’t show up for work the following day. Her family and friends, unable to reach her, were engulfed by an ever-growing dread. When news of her disappearance broke, fear rippled through their close-knit community, as everyone wondered how a lively, dedicated mother and wife could simply vanish into thin air.

In the immediate aftermath of Susan’s disappearance, Joshua’s behavior came under close scrutiny. Inexplicably, he rented a car and drove hundreds of miles, a move that baffled investigators and added fuel to the mounting suspicions against him. His shaky alibi, coupled with the peculiar circumstances of his midnight camping trip, painted a picture that was hard for anyone, including law enforcement, to ignore.

Investigations into Susan’s disappearance kicked into high gear. The police conducted extensive searches and interviewed everyone associated with Susan, but the spotlight inevitably kept turning back to Joshua. His increasingly odd behavior, coupled with inconsistencies in his statements, only added to the law enforcement’s suspicions. As a grim cloud of uncertainty shrouded Susan’s disappearance, one thing was becoming increasingly clear: Joshua Powell was a person of interest in the case of his missing wife.

Traces of Susan’s blood found in the family home further intensified these suspicions. With each passing day, the charming image of Joshua began to crumble, revealing a disturbing portrait of a man who might know more about his wife’s disappearance than he let on. As we delve into the chilling saga that unfolded in the aftermath of Susan’s disappearance, we’re forced to confront the haunting question: What happened to Susan Powell on that cold December night?

The Investigation and Joshua’s Role

As the days turned into weeks, and then months, Susan Powell remained missing. The spotlight on Joshua, her husband, grew harsher with each passing day. His odd behavior, coupled with revelations about their troubled marriage and a family life that was anything but idyllic, fueled the case’s intrigue and cast a grim shadow over Joshua. Amid the growing suspicions, the intricate web of family relations in the Powell household began to unravel, revealing a disturbing tableau of secrets and lies.

A crucial piece of the puzzle came from an unexpected source: Susan’s private journals. These intimate writings disclosed a woman living under the constant strain of an unhappy and potentially abusive marriage. The happy facade Susan projected to the world was a stark contrast to the turmoil she was experiencing behind closed doors. Susan’s journals laid bare the anxieties and fears that had plagued her, adding a deeply personal dimension to her mysterious disappearance.

In a surprising twist, Joshua and his father, Steven Powell, started a public smear campaign against Susan, claiming that she was mentally unstable and had possibly run away with another man. These allegations, aimed at tarnishing Susan’s image and diverting attention from their own suspicious actions, only served to highlight the deep-rooted dysfunction in the Powell family.

In September 2011, the case took an even darker turn when Steven Powell was arrested on charges of voyeurism and child pornography. Among the victims of Steven’s prying lens was his own daughter-in-law, Susan. This damning revelation led to a fierce custody battle, resulting in Susan’s father, Chuck Cox, being granted temporary custody of her two young sons.

Adding further fuel to the fire, Jennifer Graves, Joshua’s own sister, publicly accused her brother of being involved in Susan’s disappearance. Jennifer’s bold and damning accusation exposed the deep rifts within the Powell family and put Joshua further into the spotlight. Despite the mounting suspicion against Joshua, the authorities struggled to find concrete evidence linking him directly to Susan’s disappearance.

In the midst of this maelstrom, Joshua Powell remained a perplexing and elusive figure. His actions, both before and after Susan’s disappearance, painted a deeply troubling picture. As investigators delved deeper into the Powell family’s secrets, the question that hovered ominously over everything was not just “Where is Susan Powell?” but also “What role did Joshua Powell play in her disappearance?” The search for answers to these questions would take investigators down a harrowing path filled with more twists, turns, and shocking revelations.

The Tragic Explosion

Just when it seemed that the saga surrounding Susan Powell’s disappearance couldn’t get any more tragic or bizarre, an unthinkable event shocked the nation. On February 5, 2012, during what was meant to be a routine supervised visit with his sons, Joshua Powell’s house suddenly erupted in a catastrophic explosion. The blast claimed the lives of Joshua and his two young sons, Charles and Braden. It was a gruesome and horrifying scene, an appalling act of violence that sent shockwaves through the community and the nation at large.

The authorities were swift to label the incident as a deliberate double murder-suicide. Evidence of premeditation started to surface soon after the explosion. Just minutes before the tragic event, Joshua had sent emails to several people, bidding them farewell. He had withdrawn a substantial amount of money and donated his children’s belongings. Perhaps most chillingly, he named his brother, Michael Powell, as the sole beneficiary of his life insurance. These actions spoke volumes about Joshua’s state of mind in his final moments and painted a terrifying picture of a man ready to commit an unthinkable act.

In the aftermath of the explosion, the public and the investigators were left to grapple with this horrifying end to Joshua and his children’s lives. Any hope of gleaning definitive answers from Joshua about Susan’s disappearance was now lost forever. Amid the shock and grief, the pressing question of Susan’s whereabouts remained unanswered.

The tragedy took another twist about a year later when Michael Powell, who had always been somewhat evasive when questioned about Susan’s disappearance, took his own life. This unexpected development added yet another layer of darkness and complexity to the harrowing saga of the Powell family. The possibility of new leads or information from Michael vanished, leaving the investigators and the public to wonder about the secrets he might have taken with him to his grave.

The tragic explosion and its aftermath marked a gruesome climax to the chilling series of events that had started with Susan’s disappearance. It left a haunting legacy of unanswered questions and a longing for justice that remained frustratingly out of reach.

The Lingering Mystery

Susan Powell’s story, tragically marred by a maze of dark secrets, unthinkable acts, and a gaping void where answers should be, doesn’t end with the shocking explosion and subsequent tragedies. The shadow of her disappearance continues to loom large, with the lingering question: “Where is Susan?” Despite the passage of time, the mystery of her whereabouts remains as haunting as ever.

In early 2022, over a decade after Susan’s disappearance, there was a glimmer of hope that the answer might finally be found. An exploration team, delving into the desolate stretches of the Utah desert, stumbled upon bone fragments and scraps of clothing hidden in a remote cave. The discovery stirred hopes and fears alike. However, tests revealed that the remains were non-human, and the clothing bore male DNA, dashing hopes of a breakthrough in Susan’s case. Yet, this development underlined the tenacity of those seeking the truth and the lengths they were willing to go in their quest for justice.

Susan’s disappearance is widely believed to be the result of a murder, with Joshua as the prime suspect. Yet, this belief rests on a bed of assumptions and circumstantial evidence, as no concrete proof has come to light to verify this theory. The very lack of answers fuels the tragic allure of Susan’s case, making it an enduring mystery that continues to captivate public attention and raise pressing questions about family, trust, and the perils that sometimes lurk behind the most ordinary façades.

Deep Lore 3: Murders, Mysteries, and Missing Pieces Deep Lore

In this episode of Deep Lore, we delve into the heart of stories that defy closure and haunt our collective consciousness. We start with The Haunting Case of Elaine Johnson, a Thanksgiving that ended in eerie silence, and move to 47 Years Later: The Murder of Sigrid Stevenson, where mysteries still lurk within Kendall Hall. We revisit The Unsolved Murders of Russell & Shirley Dermond, and explore the baffling disappearance in Left in the Dark: The Mystery of Iraena Asher. Finally, we unravel The Perplexing Murder of Christopher Thomas, where each detail deepens the enigma. Join us as we explore why these unsolved cases grip us, highlighting the human need for answers in the face of the unknowable. http://DeepLore.tv
  1. Deep Lore 3: Murders, Mysteries, and Missing Pieces
  2. Deep Lore 2: Fragments of the Unknown
  3. Deep Lore 1: Echoes of the Missing
  4. Allan Menzies + Essex Boys Murders + Joan Vollmer Exorcism
  5. Abby Choi Murdered! + Retta McCabe A Psycho? + Sao Paulo Girl Hoax?

Leave a comment