The Detective, The Journalist, and the Killer: Suspects in the Circleville Case

Beginning in 1976, an anonymous letter writer terrorized Circleville, Ohio, exposing secrets and threatening lives. After one death and an attempted murder by booby trap, police convicted Paul Freshour. Yet, the letters continued to arrive while he was imprisoned, turning the case into one of America's most perplexing cold cases. Decades later, the true identity of the writer remains a mystery.

Three Minutes to Midnight: The Unsolved Murder of Brian Foguth

On the night of November 28, 1994, 23-year-old Brian Foguth clocked in at the Duke and Duchess convenience store in Brimfield, Ohio. He wasn’t supposed to be there. Brian had agreed to cover a shift for a coworker, a last-minute favor he didn’t hesitate to accept. The store sat at the edge of town, where … Continue reading Three Minutes to Midnight: The Unsolved Murder of Brian Foguth

Tonetta Carlisle’s Last Walk: The 35-Year Search for Truth Behind a Tennessee Teen’s Vanishing

It was a Thursday afternoon, March 16, 1989, and the streets of Chattanooga, Tennessee, were calm. The school day had just ended, and 15-year-old Tonetta Carlisle was on her way home. She walked this route every day—a quick five-minute stroll from City High School to her house on Ruth Avenue. She wasn't in a rush, … Continue reading Tonetta Carlisle’s Last Walk: The 35-Year Search for Truth Behind a Tennessee Teen’s Vanishing

Was She Running From Danger or Her Own Mind? The Vanishing of Star Palumbo

It’s the early hours of April 26, 2000, at Reno/Tahoe International Airport. The world beyond is quiet and still, but on the tarmac, a strange scene unfolds. A young woman is running erratically across the open expanse, moving with a frantic urgency that suggests she’s trying to escape from an unseen threat. Her name is … Continue reading Was She Running From Danger or Her Own Mind? The Vanishing of Star Palumbo

Mystery in Belle Haven: The Unsolved Case of Martha Moxley

On the night of October 30, 1975, the quiet streets of Belle Haven, a gated community in Greenwich, Connecticut, were alive with mischief. It was Mischief Night, a local tradition when kids played harmless pranks—egging houses, draping trees in toilet paper, ringing doorbells, and dashing away into the night. For 15-year-old Martha Moxley, it was … Continue reading Mystery in Belle Haven: The Unsolved Case of Martha Moxley

The (un)Solved Murders of Brandon Adams & Christine Marcelin

In the vibrant heart of New Orleans, where the pulsing beats of jazz often echo through the streets, a chilling silence fell on April 27th, 2012. On this day, the city’s rhythm was disrupted not by celebration but by a harrowing act of violence that would leave two families shattered and a community grappling with … Continue reading The (un)Solved Murders of Brandon Adams & Christine Marcelin

The Haunting Case of Elaine Johnson: A Thanksgiving That Led to Silence

On Thanksgiving Day, 1990, forty-one-year-old Elaine Johnson's apartment in Parma, Ohio's Kimberly Park complex stood quiet—neat, organized, the home of a meticulous person. She'd raised two kids, worked a steady job at the Tri-C Unified Technology Center, and by all accounts, was doing her best to hold life together. But this Thanksgiving, something wasn't right. … Continue reading The Haunting Case of Elaine Johnson: A Thanksgiving That Led to Silence

47 Years Later, the Murder of Sigrid Stevenson Still Haunts New Jersey’s Kendall Hall

In Livermore, California, nestled 40 miles east of San Francisco, young Sigrid Miller Stevenson’s world was filled with the quiet intensity of art and nature. Born on January 24, 1952, Sigrid was the eldest daughter of Peter and Barbara Stevenson. Her father, a Marine turned nuclear chemist, had a disciplined love for music that spilled … Continue reading 47 Years Later, the Murder of Sigrid Stevenson Still Haunts New Jersey’s Kendall Hall